Discussion about this post

User's avatar
I'm Still Writing's avatar

Beautifully, soulfully written. Thank you. I love its poignant honesty and admire you for writing this. Your voice is wonderful, engaging, and there is definitly something "there" that pulls at me. You are 100% right here: "It bothers me because the people reading Finding the Kingdom deserve my voice—not an AI’s interpretation of what fantasy prose is supposed to sound like." We do deserve your true voice. I will definitely be back. May the road rise up to meet you every time you sit down to write.

Fiona Wilding 🏰 CastleClearing's avatar

I found the same thing. I'm recently returned to writing after many years and at first, I was using ChatGPT as an editor. But despite my instructions it kept suggesting revisions, which I sometimes used because I was unsure of my own voice. However, I ultimately found it eroded my sense of accomplishment and pride in my own work, so I stopped. I now use Claude, which obeys my strict instructions not to provide any rewrites and simply advises on readability and flow and obvious mistakes.

The thing I've noticed is that it's too easy to assume that A.I. knows better because it appears as this omniscient thing. Something that broke that illusion was putting the same piece of writing into two A.I.s and seeing what they picked up - and also copying the suggestions of one into the other for an opinion. In fact, they often disagree. So why not just do my own thing regardless?

AI has a very useful role, but it needs to be used as a tool where we retain our own sovereignty, both of knowledge and of voice. For me, I figure out what I'm thinking as I write, so it's important that the words are mine.

4 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?